All-Terrain VehiclesAuto Buying & SellingAuto RepairAutomotive IndustryCampers & MotorhomesCarsCommercial VehiclesMotorcycles & ScootersSafe DrivingTrucks, SUVs, & Vans

Driving a BMW Rear Wheel Drive in the Winter Snow and Ice

Updated on May 29, 2016

Why Are BMW's Rubbish in Winter?

How come the world’s best car is rubbish, dangerous and useless when a bit of snow and ice appears?

This article explores some of the reality of BMW winter driving, looks at reasons for their poor performance, and considers the solutions.

It is written from a UK perspective where we have occasional snow, winter tyres are an unfamiliar concept and the four wheel drive BMW is a rarity rather than the norm.

Have Your Say

Are you disappointed with your BMW in the snow?

See results

Two disappointed owners

First of all, a couple of experiences of the lunacy that a BMW on ice represents.

My neighbour attempts to drive to the shops in her BMW One Series.

She gets stuck on the camber of the road with the car sliding all over the place. It is going sideways rather than forward, and cannot get over the massive incline that a normal road camber suddenly represents.

She gives up, car is in the middle of the road, and asks me for help. I am confident - I am an experienced (and rather good in my opinion) driver, and she is a woman. I don’t say that of course.

I don’t drive a rear wheel drive.

After five or ten minutes of gently trying to persuade this piece of crap on wheels to navigate the icy road I give up. I reverse it into a passable imitation of a deliberate piece of parking – it’s off to the side of the road, no longer blocking it – and there is no hope of driving it anywhere or putting it back on her drive.

When I use my front wheel drive Toyota, no problem at all. Any skidding is purely for fun – I love doing handbrake turns when the roads are iced up. Yeah OK, I’m just a big kid – but when no one is about and the roads are sheet ice – it’s an opportunity to practice controlled slides.

The all new luxury branded snow kit is available for just under a thousand dollars.
The all new luxury branded snow kit is available for just under a thousand dollars.

The million mile driver

A colleague of mine has driven about one million miles over thirty years.

If I were to point to what I would call an experienced driver, he would be it.

He has had a variety of company cars – one every three years for thirty years – and does thirty thousand odd miles a year.

Two years ago he got a BMW 3 series – good mileage, low CO2 and all round ticks the boxes for company taxation benefits.

He says he will never get a BMW again. In winter it is an absolute menace with loss of grip, a no goer in the ice and snow – he sees it as dangerous.

His company won’t stump up the extra money for winter tyres so he will suffer this car until it is time for the next model.

"Brother Gary's Beemer is stuck on the M25 in one inch of snow but he hopes we have a good supper"
"Brother Gary's Beemer is stuck on the M25 in one inch of snow but he hopes we have a good supper"

What’s the Problem?

I can’t believe that BMW’s are rubbish cars. They are desired by many drivers and they are great to drive.

So why do they turn into an object of ridicule over winter?

The BMW driver is the one parked up or sliding across the road – while the theoretically crappy 1.1 Panda sails serenely along – unaffected by a bit of snow or ice.

One theory is that BMW drivers are badge obsessed idiots who don’t know how to drive properly.

Well that’s a theory but it doesn’t help when you have gently tried to negotiate a road camber in the ice using years of driving experience.

Let’s ignore that and put it down to the opposite of badge obsession – badge jealousy.

The main problems are…

Rubber - the compound for summer tyres is effective down to about 7 degrees Celcius. Below that it hardens rapidly. The winter tyre silica rubber mix is optimised for lower temperatures.

Rear wheel drive – an eye opener for someone like me who drives a front wheel drive. I could not believe how much harder to control a spinning back wheel is compared to a spinning front wheel.

Weight distribution – the perfect 50/50 of the BMW’s is not as good as the engine over the front wheel drive arrangement for winter conditions.

Tyre width – there are complex arguments about grip distribution and the actions on snow. I am not a physicist.

Run flat tyres – I am dubious about these anyway. They seem like a compromise to me, or maybe I am just being old fashioned.

Performance – the BMW tends not to be a gentle car to drive, it is a power machine.

One of the key elements, and one that is hard to get round, is that in cold weather the rubber of the summer tyre hardens. It becomes naturally less grippy, at a time of year with leaves, wet, ice and snow when you need it most.

Every rear wheel drive BMW should come with a free snow shovel
Every rear wheel drive BMW should come with a free snow shovel

What is that juddering sound?

That sound is the noise made when the automatic anti-slip systems come into play.

If a wheel loses grip - either when braking or accelerating - the power or brake will be temporarily interrupted.

This enables the worst of the slipping to be controlled.

It is a sign that you are driving too hard or the roads are particularly slippy. In any case you should take it as a warning and be as gentle as possible.

Danger - BMW Ahead!
Danger - BMW Ahead!

Solutions - Cheap

There are a few short cuts which might improve things, or might make your car even more dangerous.

These are purely down to you, and your experimentation.

Driving technique. All the old boring stuff about starting in second gear, being gentle, leaving lots of space, anticipation. All very well and good, but if the car cannot negotiate an icy camber on a road, it doesn’t really matter how skilled a driver you are.

Weight in the boot. Sandbags, cement, kerbstones – anything that gives a degree of extra weight over the rear wheels will probably help traction. At first I thought that would be a great idea until I read about weight distribution and the need to be able to steer as well as move forward!

If you overload the rear weight, you may compromise the steering at the other end.

Deflate the tyres slightly. It might help, but it is not an area I would want to get into. You buy a perfectly made balanced driving machine, and then fiddle about with it to persuade it to run ‘safely’ in winter conditions. I don’t believe this is a sensible or safe solution.

Wheel gloves. These are emergency, get you home, solutions for a bit of snow. They do not offer months of safe winter driving, they will last for a few miles that’s all.

Do not overdo the additional weight in the rear or you can affect front-wheel steering
Do not overdo the additional weight in the rear or you can affect front-wheel steering

Solutions – Winter Tyres – Expensive

I believe a set of winter tyres for a One series comes in at about one thousand pounds. That includes wheels as well, because they have different dimensions to the usual wheels.

Note. I'm not sure about the dimensions being different. It may be because they are run flats, see below.

At first glance that seems ridiculous, and of course it is, but then you get used to an amount of excessive pricing with BMW. It’s how they make their money.

Winter tyres would appear to be the right solution, although costly.

In Germany, they are required by law to change to winter tyres for several months. Overall the tyre wear is half as much as normal, because you change twice a year, so the total cost is not much more than just using one set of normal tyres.

There is no such law in the UK, and winter tyres are still a bit of a rarity. Unless you have been struggling with your BMW over the last couple of hard UK winters.

It might be possible to pick up a set of second hand winter tyres for your model, or to cut a more reasonable deal with a local garage.

In my opinion, having read as much information as I can bear on the subject, winter tyres are the only option to keep running through the bad winter periods.

A set of winter tyres for the BMW is astronomically expensive
A set of winter tyres for the BMW is astronomically expensive

Other Less Likely Solutions

Get rid of your BMW and buy something else. After the experience of winter driving this is an attractive idea. But it’s costly to change for something that should just work.

Buy a winter runabout – a secondhand front wheel drive anything – that works in bad conditions. In all seriousness, a piece of ‘crap’ like a 1.1 Fiat will out perform your Beemer. Five hundred pounds and up, plus road tax, insurance, and so on.

Don’t go anywhere. “I won’t be in today, I have a BMW” – a great excuse (not) for avoiding work and social engagements during the winter months.

If only you could test drive a rear-wheel drive BMW in the snow before buying...
If only you could test drive a rear-wheel drive BMW in the snow before buying...

Run Flat Winter Tyres

A little bit more info on these.

Why do you have to buy steel wheels, steels, when it would seem all you need to do is swap the summer tyres with the winter ones and then back again?

It's because run flats are special. They 'might' come off and back on again perfectly well. Or they might not.

So the proper way to do it is to get a spare set of wheels with the winter tyres on, and swap the whole lot come spring or autumn.

The price these tyres are anyway who would want to risk having a few fail when it comes to putting them back on?

Traction Tip

From Dom in the comments.

If you need extra wheel grip to get out of a stuck situation, try turning off the traction control.

This should give you more control over what the wheels are doing.

Another Traction Tip

If you are stuck on an incline with loss of traction it ‘might’ be possible to gain extra traction by using the handbrake.

Apparently it is possible that one rear wheel can be slipping, while the other is not doing anything due to the slip differential (whatever that is).

By using the handbrake, gently!, it can slow down the spinning wheel and divert some power towards the non moving wheel.

In theory this might enable both rear wheels to put some effort in.

I haven’t tried this, it sounds a bit ‘rally’ style to me, but I am prepared to be very impressed if someone masters it.

Emergency Supplies

A lot of cat litter was sold last year. And salt.

Buy now while stocks last.

The cat litter is not for use inside your car if you are, er, stuck without a toilet – it’s for scattering under the rear drive wheels to get some quick grip and get moving.

I’ll add to this list when I get stuck and remember the things I should have brought with me.

Winter coat, drinks, something to wee in, torch, charged phone, keep that fuel topped up, and so on.

It would be madness to drive out when there is an inch of snow on the ground
It would be madness to drive out when there is an inch of snow on the ground

UK Weather Note

For overseas visitors.

The UK does not normally get a lot of snow so we are unable to deal with it.

One inch is enough to cause absolute traffic chaos.

We had TWO whole inches a while back and some unlucky drivers were stuck in their cars overnight for twelve miserable hours.

Stay at Home When It's Snowing

The great thing about owning a rear wheel drive car is that you won't be expected to come into work.

Every one knows they are lethal in the snow and ice. And nobody wants to be stuck behind one while the owner attempts to drive in a straight line.

So do yourself and other drivers a favour and take a day off.

BMW Sales Spiel

"Yes Sir, these are the best cars money can buy.  A drivers machine, engineered, precision, expensive.  Winter driving? Oh well, you'll need to buy another car if you want to do that"
"Yes Sir, these are the best cars money can buy. A drivers machine, engineered, precision, expensive. Winter driving? Oh well, you'll need to buy another car if you want to do that"

Some Hard Questions for BMW Dealers

If you are lucky enough to be purchasing a BMW then you might like to wipe the smile off the dealer's face.

Ask him if they recommend winter tyres for their real wheel drive cars. Watch him squirm.

Ask him how much they cost and whether they will be thrown in as part of the deal.

Once you have negotiated that part then ask how they plan to service your car - swapping the tyres in and out for the winter season.

Where are they going to store the tyres?

They suggested to a friend that she take the tyres home and store them in her garage!

Yes, four tyres and wheels in the back of a One Series - for a lady owner to manhandle in and out of her car. Not what I thought the BMW owner image was about.

Ask them if they think that is the sort of service BMW should be providing? In Germany the garage stores the tyres and swaps them at NO cost.

You would think as BMW have a connection with Germany they would provide the same service for UK drivers.

If you have just realised how poorly a rear wheel drive performs in the snow and ice you might also ask your dealer - why didn't they tell you about winter tyres being a necessity not a luxury?

Yeah well. Good luck with that!

.

.

.


Comments

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • profile image

      Charmin99 3 months ago

      Cheers Dan... yes 255's on the back, M suspension, it is e90 so ECU much the same, LCi but can't see that making much difference, Bridgestones RFT, no snow... so looks like won't get a chance this year... Now it's funny you say 335xdrive tourer, good friend has one 2 years old and he still plans to leave it at home if it snows... never tried it but thinks to risky... so afraid BMW have lost the confidence of their customers.. If you read back you'll see I've made up some snow straps I want to try, basically giant tie wrap that can thread through rim and over tyre, clip it tight, 5 per r wheel, can be quick released, they are industrial use for hanging ventilation ducting apparently... so hence waiting for snow... haha.

      Cheers

    • profile image

      Dan 3 months ago

      Hello Charmin 99, car is a 320d efficient dynamics , 225/45/17 all round, tyres bridgestone potenzas RFTs.... Again we had some snow a couple of week back since I wrote this had about a day of snow, didn't get stuck.... Does your car have the wider rears ? 255? That won't help.... Also your car been a petrol is Alot more free revving than my sluggish diesel which helps with revs and clutch control.

      Also yours is an msport model? Again the firmer suspension and I assume bigger alloys and wider tyres won't help your car.

      Fresh snow never had a problem, how ever compacted snow takes a fair while to get moving.

      I'm that happy with my car I'll be trading it in for a new shape 335d xdrive tourer soon.

      Also is your car an older model which doesn't have as good computer systems, my current 320d is a e90

    • profile image

      Charmin99 4 months ago

      Dan... this is either a wind up or you have winter tyres fitted and don't know it... I've got the 320i M and have used and tried turning off the DTC and DCS (5 second push) in the snow, yes it is a fraction better but we are talking about trying to get the car off my drive... a slight camber, get the rear wheels in the gutter and that's it.... dig it out of 2 inches of snow... !! trying to actually go up a hill in the snow is something most of us BMW drivers can only dream of. Perhaps you've got a 4x4 as well and didn't know it, or are you certain it's snow...? in the rain I agree you could do it, just about... haha.

      I am hoping it snows down here on the south coast UK, well one day on a Sunday will do just to try everything out again and have another play just to remind me how bad it is, was...

      Cheers

    • profile image

      Dan 4 months ago

      I live in UK, Yorkshire at the bottom of a steepish hill (especially to think about getting up when covered in snow).

      Yet my 320d (manual) has never once got stuck any where in the snow and I'm not one to shy away when it does snow.

      I don't use snow tyres or socks or put grit on my wheels, all I do is press the dtc button (keep hold of it for about 5 seconds and a different icon appears which turns off everything not just the traction) put it in 2nd gear and then just clutch control and it just gives the right amount of slip to bite into snow and it soon gets into a stride, once rolling press dtc button once and all systems turn back on and leave it in 2nd until at the top of snowy hill....

      The only time I have ever had trouble is getting the car to stop on snow, but for Best results I use a low gear to keep revs high (better engine braking) and the brake pedal very very lightly.

      Hope this helps some one out (please remember to press dtc button once moving as if depressed for the 5ish seconds it does literally turn off all safety systems except stuff like air bags and means the car won't try auto correct and auto brake on individual wheels if you go into a spin.

      Dan

    • profile image

      Vlad 4 months ago

      Completely not true. I have been driving a RWD BMW for 2 years now. Got in alot of snow and ice every winter. It snowed 40cm of snow this week in the area I live. No problem driving it where every other car goes. Does it handle different? It does. But no problem going around.

    • profile image

      Caesonia 4 months ago

      You know, this bit of sputter fits into the endless arguments about FWD vs RWD in snow, and then there is the rest of the time. Performance cars with performance setups, and performance rubber - AKA summer rubber - all handle like heck in snow. And that includes FWD, I am sorry.

      People said Volvos were bad in snow. Really? Winter rubber and I am literally pushing snow with the bumper. I had a separate set of rims, and while the ones for the BMW are more, I think I paid 450$ for a used set with almost new Blizzaks, and the TPS sensors all good. Car is fine until it's simply too deep. I find they will last about 7 years before needing to replace the rubber.

      I now have BMWs, because I really do prefer RWD cars, and while it has a harder time than my 240 Volvos, that's no surprise. Stiffer suspension, wider wheels to float, more power, all kinds of things that make it a joy to drive. It will also get away from you faster, if you don't pay attention, because they are sensitive cars, especially the 3 and 5 series. It's still a heck of a lot better than my F350 dually without any weight in the back, and I drive by SUVs sliding all over when I have winter tyres on. Oh...and I can fricken' STOP.

      I honestly don't understand the hate here. Get some wheel socks, if you don't want to spend the money on winter rubber. Theya re cheap, and you shouldn't be driving that fast anyways if the roads are that icky. If you ended up in a ditch, you had no clue about how to drive the car, and that's not BMWs fault. IN the US, they will actually give a day's training including how to do complete 380s if you buy a new car from them. That teaches you how to drive the car correctly.

      See how well your little econo box Vauxhaul does against your maligned 1 series in the wet, or in the summer. Guess whose wheels will be spinning, and whose won't? The BMW will leave you in the dust. Big surprise.

      Sheesh, sometimes I do mountain climb challenges with the car on AS touring rubber in light snow just to see what happens. 95% of the time, the car just goes. 5%, when someone blocks my uphill process at just the wrong moment, I am done. Is it annoying if its a light? Yes, but a little sand behind the wheel and 6 inches and you go. With winter rubber, it wouldn;t have been a problem. And its still FUN. And the car still handles better than any econo box Toytoa.

      Just, get over it. Or buy an AWD BMW.

    • profile image

      Great white north 4 months ago

      Canadian here. BMW 330e rear drive with proper winter tires.

      Winter tires are the only way to go in any climate where the temperature even approaches freezing. Winter tires have a HUGE advantage starting around 7 degrees C as the softer rubber compound does not get hard like a hockey puck.

      Just drove 3000 km through 40cm of snow on highways in Ontario and Wisconsin. No problems whatsoever. I have a Subaru too and I like the fact that rear wheel drive in the BMW gives me hints that the pavement is getting slippery before I need to use brakes.

    • profile image

      Lizzard 7 months ago

      So many younger people have never driven a red vehicle. Not as good in the snow but so very much better in all situations, not to mention tons more fun . No torque steer & light precise steering more than make up for a little extra snow drive ability and being pushed through a curve instead of pulled. It is the first feature I look for in a car.

    • charmin99 profile image

      charmin99 7 months ago

      Hi Alan, you never know, the rubber might have perished before it shows again... ;-)

      But to be honest, it says it all, "I had to buy a second hand set of wheels and tyres off eBay to be able to drive my very expensive BMW in the snow..." it could have been worse, you could have picked them up in a charity shop...

      Cheers

    • profile image

      Alan Porter 7 months ago

      I bought some 16" wheels from a Z3 for my 320D SE E91 which has 17 x 225 x45 tyres. I bought 16 x 205 x 55 tyres. Same circumference so no gearing or Speedo issues. Wheels from eBay.

      No snow since I got them 2 years ago.

    • charmin99 profile image

      charmin99 8 months ago

      Hi Jack, congrats on yr new car, so we will all wait in anticipation for the snow and perhaps when your at work and can't get to your old land rover... I personally can hardly wait for you to come back on here and let us know your BMW snow experience, your apologies, your new understanding, your humility for being such a dumb ase before the fact, you will return, the the always do.

      Cheers

    • profile image

      Jack 8 months ago

      My first three cars were rear wheel drive in the late fifties early sixties front wheel drive was rare. Then we bought an old Landrover for the very bad weather

      I have just taken delivery of a new 5series d530 sportI don' expect it to handle very well in icy conditions so I have kept my 20 year old Range Rover

      So if you can afford a high powered BMW don't winge buy an old 4*4 to knock about in in bad conditions

    • profile image

      Mike 11 months ago

      Best cars for the snow were the Sierra and Granada Scorpio 4x4's, the very best forsafe driving in it and much improved roadholding in all conditions. Their viscous coupling diffs were much superior to the other 4x4 cars such as Audi, Skoda, Subaru and so on, they have systems that activate the second axle which usually causes a sudden change, the Ford Ferguson system is continuously connected so works all the time. Winter tyres don't cost a fortune and are excellent, just don't use the stupid run flat ones which are a rediculous price just so the manufacturer doesn't have to provide a spare.

    • charmin99 profile image

      charmin99 11 months ago

      Hi guys... nice round-up, anyway, no snow where I am in the UK since 2013, so still not tried my own design snow straps, this is a real double edged sword, don't want snow... do want snow.. haha.

      Anyway to Tommo the tosser, yea fit winter tyres... I make that £1000 x 3 years = £3000 for no snow and a waste of time tyres... cheers dumbo..

      It'll snow this year now.... !!

      Cheers

    • profile image

      j.martinez 11 months ago

      ok can't be bothered to read a load o crap boring comments!.the fact is the bmw rear wheel drive system is " totally crap"had a 2016 bmw parked on a cravel base that has a slight incline," it failed big time"thats in summer no snow & totally dry condition's. ye its a really nice car" but"BMW GET UR F!!!!NG ACT TOGETHER " really pathetic":( :( :(

    • Mark Ewbie profile image
      Author

      Mark Ewbie 16 months ago from Euroland

      Lol ze - cool friend comment!

    • profile image

      ze 16 months ago

      hi

      im driving a bmw 330d (306 hp) in central europe, i have snoe 3 months in the year... well, driving a bmw in snow its like go out with friend, you know how it starts but dont know how it gonna end... if you have a FWD, you cant drive a RWD in snow, you have to know what the car gonna do, and its very very diferent comparing to a FWD, but if you have good winter tyres and a ligth rigth foot, you can drive all the year, but off course, for those who dont have much expirience with driving in snow and driving a RWD its hard...

    • profile image

      Austin 2 years ago

      I guess someone never heard of the legendary 325ix... and supprised you didn't mention any of BMW newer AWD X-Drive models. They are far more effective than most AWD cars and certainly more effective than FWD or RWD. Sounds to me like you just want to bash on BMW...Shame on you!!

    • heidithorne profile image

      Heidi Thorne 2 years ago from Chicago Area

      I just saw this in the "Also from Mark Ewbie" area. Too funny! However, I can sympathize on the "run flat" tires. Had 'em on a van. What a nightmare in the cold! We'd barricade the whale in the garage for almost the entire winter since, well, we're in Chicago... land of the never ending winter and "Slip Slidin' Away..." When I had to replace a run flat that did go flat, it was about $400+ USD. When I traded in the van, I got all-wheel drive. Lesson learned. Voted up and funny, of course. Hope it's springtime where you are. We're FINALLY up above freezing and will be doing the happy dance when our May 15 frost date passes. Woohoo!

    • profile image

      Nessimmersion 2 years ago

      Mmmmm - it appears a lot of people can neither read the manual, drive their car or know the basics about tyres.

      Just had a warmer than average winter with less snow than normal, my BM was fine on snow, forestry slopes & tracks of up to 16" snow were no problem, I used hill descent mode to come down back to the public road after skiiing, again no issues - weird eh? and I'm not german!.

      Point 1 - snow tyres & winter tyres are different. In the UK there is no need to buy snow tyres. For the last time - sporty rear wheel drive cars with summer performance tyres do not perform well below 7 degrees.

      The reason 70's cars performed better in winter is the tyres were more similar to an all weather, were thinner & lest we forget, just how good was a 70s car at a) starting in winter in the first place, b) going fast round a corner in any weather c) remember the Capri - mine went sideways at any roundabout tackled at more than 25 mph !!!.

      Small reminder - if you fit winter tyres - your summer tyres aren't getting worn out at the same time - cos they are not on the car.

      Drving a car with summer tyres in winter is like driving with defective brakes, there is a reason a lot of conti countries treat this as an offence, inability to stop is hazarding other road users, pedestrians etc.

      It's a good laugh poking fun at the average british drivers inability to go round corners in the winter & the way our roads / airports / trains come to a grinding halt in 1" of snow, while the continentals keep going with 10 times as much, but really - it's a bit pathetic as well.

    • charmin99 profile image

      charmin99 2 years ago

      Hi Barney, Woody

      We all agree with you, but the question really is, do you fit winter tyres (tires) for a few days snow here in the UK (south) or do you live with the inherent poor handling in the snow without, and just stick to normal tyres.

      You see all the cars I've had before, without winter tyres, have never been good in snow, but nothing compared to my BMW, and that's what gets people going... my 1975 Ford Cortina could have knocked spots off the BMW....!!

      Comments from earlier...

      "I should read back some of the comments, it's all been said before, however it doesn't detract from the simple answer to your comments is Yes BMW rear wheel drive with normal tyres are ##** in the snow, simple as that. But do you fit £800 worth of tyres for some few days of snow, or perhaps as this year down south in the UK, no snow..."

      Buy a BMW, doesn't have to be to sporty, not 4 wheel drive, like mine a 320 I M, if it snows and you can get it off the drive with normal tyres, I'm certain Mark will hail you as good as a German driver... haha. Thanks for your comments, they all add to the good banter in this blog. Cheers.

    • profile image

      Barney 2 years ago

      Err BMW's have a snow setting...

      Read the manual

    • profile image

      Woody 2 years ago

      Clearly most people don't know how to drive. My wife has had a 320i for 5 years rwd and it is one of the best cars we have had in the snow except for our AWD cars. Often we will take the BMW when it is snowing instead of our 4x4 F150 supercrew.

      We live in Canada and the only time we have any trouble is when we have over a foot of snow and the car just gets hung up because the car doesn't have that kind of ground clearance. When winter starts we put on snow tires add 2-50lb traction bags in the trunk over the rear wheels. Once we do that the car is a beast.

      When the snow is really deep I shut the traction control off so when the car spins I can keep the rpms up to plow through the snow.

    • profile image

      graham 2 years ago

      Try reading the manual. Pressing the DSC button once briefly disables the giro and allows the car to move around a bit more before cutting power to the the wheels.

    • Mark Ewbie profile image
      Author

      Mark Ewbie 2 years ago from Euroland

      Glad you are OK Mary and maybe there is more than a little wrong with British roads and our general inability to cope.

    • profile image

      Mary Day 2 years ago

      Forget winter tyres. I came off the road on Saturday in East Yorkshire and needed rescuing from ditch. Car has fairly new winter tyres on which it had just been to Vienna then St Anton. Me and car unscathed but now I know all about rear wheel drive and, sadly, will never feel the same again about driving this lovely old lady.

    • profile image

      john 2 years ago

      Have winter tyres on rented x1 sdrive, they weren't any use on a moderate icy incline. Had to wait for the deinst and watch all the cheap cars pass me by. BMW Traction control means you stop all traffic until you can try to slide gracefully backwards off the road because its solution is to stop you completely in the center of the road. I should have taken the skoda

    • profile image

      Shawn 2 years ago

      From Canada.

      I drive a RWD BMW. It's better then most sedans. You need a full tank of gas to give the rear end weight and a decent set of all seasons (minimally) summers won't cut it. I have winters and have driven in every storm that has happened in southern Ontario and Calgary Alberta.

      I find it has nothing to do with the car and everything to do with its driver, and tires.

    • profile image

      uniclic 2 years ago

      Can't wait to try out my 330d, first winter, we'll see

    • Mark Ewbie profile image
      Author

      Mark Ewbie 2 years ago from Euroland

      Lol SDean - point well made but a large number of those sporty BMWs are sadly bought by rich people with no clue how to drive them. Arguably. Perhaps the dealer should suggest a Corolla...

    • profile image

      SDean 2 years ago

      The point is though, BMW don't pick the options list. The CUSTOMER does.

      If someone options SPORT package in a place that snows all the time they are fools.

      Im sure BMW of Finland, or Norway don't sell cars assuring their custoners that a 255/40-ZR18 Bridgestone RE050 will be just great in ice and snow.

      Horses for courses sir...

      Your next article should detail how the latest Corolla absolutely sucks for trackday use and the MXV4 tires delaminated on lap 5 and the car understeered horribly compared to the Porsches, BMWs and Lotuses....

    • Mark Ewbie profile image
      Author

      Mark Ewbie 2 years ago from Euroland

      Thanks SDean - my main beef is with BMW supplying a car with tires that are not really suitable for winter driving. Most of us are not professional rally drivers - just trying to drive to work and back. Thanks for your advice on widths - that is interesting.

    • profile image

      SDean 2 years ago

      So, you do realize BMW's are sports sedans right? They aren't econo-boxes with crap skinny tires and horrible weight distribution.

      Your complaints are the equivalent of crying that a shovel doesn't work good for hammering nails....

      The problem is not RWD, or even 50/50 weight distribution. The problem is the TIRES. Many BMW buyers choose sport options, and most BMW sport packages include summer rated, 255mm (or wider) rear tires! Wide tires float on snow.

      For snow use, I would recommend a tire no wider than 195. If you want to use the winter tires all year round, maybe put a 205 on all 4 corners.

      -Professional race driver with rally+snow experience.

    • profile image

      David 2 years ago

      So they're saying bmw suck in winter? All I gotta say is a lot people must not know how to drive because I live in the mountains an my bmw does fantastic. Sure the rear slides a little but what's a little countersteer? Drove through a good 4" of snow or more on the road up mountains and areas four wheel drives were gettin stuck on summer tread that had almost not tread. Got hung up once because of my own fault playing around. Btw in the 4" or more didn't slip a tire. Just take it slow and easy and your gravy..e36 baby. Also driving a standard is a huge benifet in snow with a rear wheel drive. Autos suck cause you get stuck. 5 speed? Lug itdown in 4th or 5th and be on your way. Learn how to drive and a bmw is fantastic in the snow.

    • profile image

      Stormbusta 2 years ago

      With regard to the comments about Winter tyres being an un-neccesary expense for 1 or 2 days of snow... I don't think you are giving this proper thought. OK, the extra expense of £1K for a set of 4 Wheels and Tyres, seems outrageous for the few days a year when we actually get snow. So I understand you are thinking, why waste £1k for a few days every year. You are not really understanding the key point of changing your tyres. If you have Summer, Low Profile tyres, and as most cars these days are fitted with Summer tyres, you probably have got them, they are not going to give good grip when the temperature falls below 7ºC. That is a fact. The rubber compound of Summer Tyres hardens significantly below 7ºC and when you are driving on cold surfaces, with rock salt, these tyres will wear out significantly quicker and will sustain more damage than on Hot roads because they do not have enough'Give'. This is simply because Summer Tyres have less 'Silica' compound in them. This is the stuff that keeps rubber soft in sub-zero temperatures. But just think about it... You need to have tyres on your car whenever you want to drive it, so.... if you buy winter tyres, your summer tyres will last longer anyway, so the only real Extra Expense is for the Extra Wheels. I'm lucky enough to have the space in my massive double garage for 2 spare sets(1 for mine and 1 for the wife's) and once you make the original 'Investment' for the extra wheels, the tyres don't cost any more. Alternatively, you could try an 'All Round' tyre suitable for both summer and Winter use if you don't want the extra expense of another set of wheels. Personally, I like to protect my Gorgeous 19" wheels (and Expensive Summer tyres) on my Rear Wheel Drive CLS and am happy to put on 17inch alloys with winter tyres on for 4-5 months of the year (October to End of March usually). All you who say a BMW or any other similar performance RWD car are useless in the snow, have obviously never tried them in the snow. I point you to this: 2 years ago when we had an early snow downfall (5 inches here in West Yorkshire) it caught a lot of people out. I had my winters on my CLS and managed to negotiate some slippery inclines. I had to visit a sick elderly relative at the weekend and he lived on quite a steep road, which by the weekend was not just covered in snow, but had a sheet of ice over the top of it. I was in 2 minds whether to try to drive up it, but try I did. And slowly I made it in my CLS! Behind me, I watched as a 4x4 BMW X5 tried to follow in me. He couldn't get any traction, all 4 wheels were not making any difference on this slippery surface. I watched his expression and he was in utter disbelief that a RWD had made it and his 4 wheel drive was useless. I looked carefully at the tyre/wheel package on his car, he had on huge 22" wheels which were really wide and a practically smooth summer profile tyre on all 4 corners. His choice of vehicle was OK for the conditions but the choice of tyres, completely unsuitable. It isn't the car which needs changing, it is the tyres. Get the point???

    • profile image

      charmin 99 2 years ago

      Hi nessimmersion,

      I should read back some of the comments, it's all been said before, however it doesn't detract from the simple answer to your comments is Yes BMW rear wheel drive with normal tyres are ##** in the snow, simple as that. But do you fit £800 worth of tyres for some few days of snow, or perhaps as this year down south in the UK, no snow...

      Buy a BMW, doesn't have to be to sporty, not 4 wheel drive, like mine a 320 I M, if it snows and you can get it off the drive with normal tyres, I'm certain Mark will hail you as good as a German driver... haha. Thanks for your comments, they all add to the good banter in this blog. Cheers.

    • profile image

      Nessimmersion 2 years ago

      What a load of partially informed opinion.

      So to summarise - all RWD cars with sporty suspension set ups are crap in the snw, is this just BMW or is it all RWD, is this a revelation to anyone who has driven a ford capri,(which had narrow tyres & only went round roundabouts sideways on a wet summers day).

      Every tyre review done in the northern hemisphere in the last decade has concluded that below 7 degrees you get substantially improved performance / safety/ braking especially in the wet on winter rubber ( note winter not snow)

      Some manufacturers now recommend that winter rubber is a more prudent choice for the british driver, given that you should be choosing your tyres for when you most need grip (November - 2 degrees, dark & wet). Interestingly the BMW is not the most likely car make to be in an accident in winter.

      BMW like everyone else in the sporty market, tunes their cars for sporty summer performance cos that is what sells.

      Alternatively you could just conclude that the germans manage to drive BMWs & Mercs all over the Alpine ski resorts in winter because they are just better drivers?????

    • Mark Ewbie profile image
      Author

      Mark Ewbie 2 years ago from Euroland

      Thanks charmin99 - I thought I was an OK driver too till I tried to get a woman's one series out of the middle of the road. Never knew a bit of icy camber could be so difficult to deal with. Back in my Avensis and although slipping about a bit - the front-wheel drive made everything a whole lot easier.

    • profile image

      charmin99 2 years ago

      This is hilarious, everyone has an opinion, but different... ha ha..... however quite common is " it's the driver" well of course I agree that a lot of the time it probably is.. but not always.

      The fact is I've been driving for over thirty years, front wheel, rear wheel, four wheel you name it, and in the snow, but not until did I get my 320i M did I know the real meaning of "catastropie in the snow" I do know how to drive but when you can't get the car off your driveway which has the slightest of a slope and a two inch dip where it meets the road, then you know you have met your match.

      Of course without repeating myself time and time again, this is without winter tyres, yes we know... fit them then, but for a few days snow in the South of the UK you would have to be mad, or very rich...

      So please take my (our) word for it, rear drive, BMW in the snow, with fat flat normal tyres, driven slow and careful, traction on or traction off, correct gear, slow revs, bit of handbrake, is just an embarrassment. PS no, I'm not rich or mad, well not until next winter...

    • profile image

      emil 2 years ago

      Just leran how go drive. I live in sweden and BMW is no problem to drive just idé your Brain and be Gentle...

    • profile image

      paul kent (again) 3 years ago

      That being said I drove a 2011 mustang v6 in the winter for a month. It had winter tires and it was completely hellish to drive. Throttle input became sideways motion and its excessive weight made breaking Nearly impossible.

      Food for thought

    • profile image

      Paul Kent 3 years ago

      I live in northern Alberta in Canada. Its mid April and its still snowing.

      I bought my BMW 3 series car in the winter, with stability control off yet with abs and traction control still on (this is very important) it handles really well. Really well. It has the perfect amount of over steer (better in snow) and it doesn't require gross oversteer to fix any accidental drifts due to overzealous driving in poor conditions. I was in fact convinced to purchase it in the snowy winter before ever driving in on a dry road. I do have snow tires.

      Any issues with driving in the snow is not the fault of the vehicle, rather the driver. BMW cars are driver cars and they respond to driver input. If you can't keep the car weighed properly due to inexperience you'll be off the road fast in the winter.but I can keep my BMW on the road better than in a VW or Honda or front wheel drive Lincoln,

    • Mark Ewbie profile image
      Author

      Mark Ewbie 3 years ago from Euroland

      Cheers charmin99 ! It's you guys who make it. I said my piece... now I'm learning. And yeah... what happened to snow this year?

    • charmin99 profile image

      charmin99 3 years ago

      #Mark I love this blog...

      Anyway, no snow in the UK this year so far (South of Scotland that is), so no chance to try my straps and saved at least it seems $122 by not buying snow tyres, but of course the down side is I never got to hire me 4x4 Land Rover... yet.

    • profile image

      Ryan 3 years ago

      *** This article is total garbage *** I own an 2004 325ci w/ 2 cheap "sunny snow tires" 225/45/17 at 61$ ea... I haven't gotten stuck yet, even driving through 7" of heavy wet snow on a 30° incline... Although I will say this...

      I turn off the traction control if I'm driving up an incline, that gives me full control to spin the rear wheels instead of cutting off the power... The snow tires dig right through with the tires spinning.

      traction control on if I'm driving on the highway or back roads for extra safety. .

      30% relays on driver experience with rear wheel drive cars

      50% relays on actual "snow" tires

      20% relays on bmw ' s 50/50 weight distribution

    • profile image

      mikeyr 3 years ago

      Just an update on the SnoClaws I recently purchased, they were utterly disappointing. The buckle/strap mechanism were the main failure point as they would not keep the straps from loosening. I even removed the tires to ensure a tight and even fit as shown in the installation video to no avail. I would drive about 50 feet and you could hear the buckles slapping against the wheel well. Clearance (wheel well to SnoClaws) was not a problem with the SnoClaws,, I got it to look identical to the video demonstration, it's just that their buckle and strap mechanism just would not remain secured. I guess the best alternative is to buy an extra set of wheels with snow tires installed and just use them during the Winter.

      BTW, first time installation is a bear. You HAVE to install the SnoClaws while the wheel is dismounted because it's almost impossible to trim the straps that are behind the wheel with the little clearance that you have. I could barely reach behind the wheel let alone trim the strips comfortably. I do not recommend the SnoClaws for BMW owners, particularly sedan and coupe owners.

    • profile image

      mikeyr 3 years ago

      @charmin99 - I remember reading about snow straps that were fed through the spokes somewhere else other than this forum, but caution to its use was made. It seems that some types may interfere with a vehicle's brake calipers. Anyway, I hope you've checked for this problem.

      You can barely get the chains on an M Sport? That's great news for me as I believe the SnoClaws should work on my car. I just have a regular 3 Series with the sports package. It seems like it may have enough clearance. I haven't received them yet so I can't say if I have a clearance problem or not. We haven't had another significant snow storm either, just snow flurries. Will keep you posted.

    • charmin99 profile image

      charmin99 3 years ago

      @mikeyr - Had a good look at the Snow Claws website, they seemed to mention clearance a few times and for me that is the trouble I have, getting your hands in behind the top of the wheel and the arch to actually connect anything, the 'Claws' look better but fingers crossed.

      I can just about get the chains on but have to do it from the side of the tyre (towards front of car) it is the M Sport so suspension is a bit lower. This is why I came up with the straps through the spokes idea (earlier post) but that was last year and no snow as yet to try them, hard choice, snow so I can try them or no snow so I don't need to.. haha.

    • Mark Ewbie profile image
      Author

      Mark Ewbie 3 years ago from Euroland

      Very cool mikeyr - that is the rally style I was referring too. One thing worth mentioning is the need to practice some of this stuff when and where it is safe, and before you really need it.

    • profile image

      mikeyr 3 years ago

      @Mark Ewbie - Oh, ok, sorry about that. Anyway, to briefly summarize what I absorbed from that web site, the trick to getting out of the snow, if you're stuck, is by using the emergency brake as described in the "One Neat Trick" section. However, you need to do it in the following way: 1) let off of the accelerator, 2) pull up on the emergency brake while still depressing the locking button (pull it up about halfway) and then 3) ease into the accelerator. You may have to play with the emergency a little to find that "sweet spot". I tried it this morning as my car got stuck in the driveway because of ice and it worked! Not sure if it'll work in somewhat more extreme conditions, though.

    Click to Rate This Article